• 主题
高级搜索  >
历史搜索 清空历史
首页> 外文会议>Americas conference on information systems;AMCIS 2005 >Becoming a Great Reviewer for IS Journals
【24h】

Becoming a Great Reviewer for IS Journals

机译：成为IS期刊的优秀审稿人

获取原文
页面导航
  • 摘要
  • 著录项
  • 相似文献
  • 相关主题

摘要

The IS field needs more great reviewers. What is a great reviewer? In her June 2005 editorial for MIS Quarterly, CarolSaunders, the MISQ Editor in Chief, contrasts the 'gatekeeper' reviewer – one who finds and surfaces 'fatal flaws' inresearch – with the 'diamond cutter' reviewer – one who polishes manuscripts so that the gems in it can surface and shine.Others have argued that a great reviewer is a champion for the paper to the journals editors – so that uncut diamonds are notlost to the field. Our field needs great reviewers of all these types (which, some would argue, are often found in the samegreat reviewer). This panel presents advice about how to become a great reviewer for IS journals from 4 reviewers who havebeen recognized as excellent reviewers by editors of various journals in the information systems field. Collectively they willpresent 12 key characteristics of good reviews, 12 key characteristics of a review process that will produce great reviews, and4 very important golden rules of reviewing -- Dos and Don'ts. They will also distribute a list of suggested reading for thoseinterested in learning more about how to improve their reviewing skills. During the Q&A period, audience members will beasked to write their questions down and submit them to the panel chair, who will moderate them. This should allow themaximum number of questions to be posed to the panel during a short period of time.
机译：IS领域需要更多优秀的审稿人。什么是出色的评论者？ MISQ总编辑CarolSaunders在MIS Quarterly的2005年6月的社论中，将“看门人”审稿人（发现并发现“致命缺陷”研究的人）与“钻石切割者”审稿人进行了对比，后者审阅了手稿，以便对里面的宝石可以浮出水面和发光。其他人则认为，出色的审稿人对期刊编辑来说是论文的拥护者-因此未切割的钻石不会丢失。我们的领域需要所有这些类型的优秀审稿人（有些人会说，经常在同一审稿人中找到）。该小组提供了有关如何成为IS期刊的优秀审稿人的建议，该4名审稿人被信息系统领域的各种期刊的编辑者公认为优秀审稿人。他们将共同代表良好评论的12个关键特征，将产生出色评论的评论过程的12个关键特征，以及4条非常重要的评论黄金法则-“注意事项”。他们还将为有兴趣学习更多有关如何提高其审阅技巧的读者分发建议阅读清单。在问答期间，将要求观众写下问题并提交给小组主席，由小组主席主持。这应该允许在短时间内向小组提出最大数量的问题。

著录项

相似文献

  • 外文文献
  • 中文文献
  • 专利
获取原文

客服邮箱：kefu@zhangqiaokeyan.com

京公网安备：11010802029741号 ICP备案号：京ICP备15016152号-6 六维联合信息科技 (北京) 有限公司©版权所有

  • 客服微信

  • 服务号