...
首页> 外文期刊>Neurosurgical focus >Residency perception survey among neurosurgery residents in lower-middle-income countries: grassroots evaluation of neurosurgery education
【24h】

Residency perception survey among neurosurgery residents in lower-middle-income countries: grassroots evaluation of neurosurgery education

机译:中低收入国家神经外科居民的居留性感知调查:神经外科教育的基层评估

获取原文
           

摘要

OBJECTIVE The evolution of the neurosurgical specialty in lower-middle-income countries is uniformly a narrative of continuous struggle for recognition and resource allocation. Therefore, it is not surprising that neurosurgical education and residency training in these countries is relatively nascent. Dr. Harvey Cushing in 1901 declared that he would specialize in neurosurgery and gave his greatest contribution to the advancement of neurosurgical education by laying the foundations of a structured residency training program. Similar efforts in lower-middle-income countries have been impeded by economic instability and the lack of well-established medical education paradigms. The authors sought to evaluate the residency programs in these nations by conducting a survey among the biggest stakeholders in these educational programs: the neurosurgical residents. METHODS A questionnaire addressing various aspects of the residency program from a resident’s perspective was prepared with Google Forms and circulated among neurosurgery residents through social media and email groups. Where applicable, a 5-point Likert scale was used to grade the responses to the questions. Responses were collected from May to October 2019 and analyzed using descriptive statistics. Complete anonymity of the respondents was ensured to keep the responses unbiased. RESULTS A total of 195 responses were received, with 189 of them from lower-middle-income countries (LMICs). The majority of these were from India (75%), followed by Brazil and Pakistan. An abiding concern among residents was lack of work hour regulations, inadequate exposure to emerging subspecialties, and the need for better hands-on training ( 60% each). Of the training institutions represented, 89% were offering more than 500 major neurosurgical surgeries per year, and 40% of the respondents never got exposure to any subspecialty. The popularity of electronic learning resources was discernible and most residents seemed to be satisfied with the existent system of evaluation. Significant differences (p 0.05) among responses from India compared with those from other countries were found in terms of work hour regulations and subspecialty exposure. CONCLUSIONS It is prudent that concerned authorities in LMICs recognize and address the deficiencies perceived by neurosurgery residents in their training programs. A determined effort in this direction would be endorsed and assisted by a host of international neurosurgical societies when it is felt that domestic resources may not be adequate. Quality control and close scrutiny of training programs should ensure that the interests of neurosurgical trainees are best served.
机译:目的,中低收入国家的神经外科专业的演变是持续斗争的叙述,以便承认和资源分配。因此,这些国家的神经外科教育和居住培训尚未令人惊讶的是。 1901年,哈维博士宣布他将专注于神经外科,并通过奠定结构性居留培训计划的基础,为神经外科教育的进步提供了最大的贡献。中低收入国家的类似努力受到经济不稳定和缺乏良好的医学教育范式。作者试图通过这些教育计划中最大的利益相关者进行调查来评估这些国家的居留计划:神经外科居民。方法通过谷歌表格和电子邮件组在神经外科居民之间制备从居民的角度讨论居民观点的各个方面的问卷。在适用的情况下,5分Likert秤用于对问题的回应进行评分。从5月到2019年10月收集的回复,并使用描述性统计分析。确保答辩受访者的完整匿名性以使答复不偏不倚。结果总共收到了195份反应,其中189名来自中等收入国家(LMIC)。其中大多数来自印度(75%),其次是巴西和巴基斯坦。居民的持续担忧缺乏工作小时规则,不充分暴露于新兴亚特色,需要更好的动手培训(每项60%)。在培训机构,89%的人每年提供超过500个主要的神经外科手术,40%的受访者从未接触过任何亚专业。电子学习资源的普及是可辨别的,大多数居民似乎对存在的评估系统感到满意。与来自其他国家的答案相比,在工作时间规定和亚特色曝光方面发现了与其他国家的反应之间的显着差异(P <0.05)。结论谨慎的是,涉及LMIC的当局认识并解决了神经外科居民在培训方案中所感知的缺陷。当据觉得国内资源可能不充分时,这方面的一系列国际神经外科社会都将获得并协助这一方向的坚定努力。质量控制和密切审查培训计划应确保最佳服务的神经外科学员的利益。

著录项

获取原文

客服邮箱:kefu@zhangqiaokeyan.com

京公网安备:11010802029741号 ICP备案号:京ICP备15016152号-6 六维联合信息科技 (北京) 有限公司©版权所有
  • 客服微信

  • 服务号