Why Animals Can't Act

RALF STOECKER

首页> 外文期刊>Inquiry >Why Animals Can't Act

【24h】

Why Animals Can't Act

机译：为什么动物不能行动

获取原文

获取原文并翻译 | 示例

掌桥外文数据库（机构版） >>

开具论文收录证明 >>

页面导航

摘要
著录项
相似文献
相关主题

摘要

Given the many marvelous things animals can do and moreover the success we have in employing the intentional stance towards animals, it seems to be almost unthinkable to say that animals could not act at all. Nonetheless, this is exactly what I argue for. I claim that strictly speaking there is no animal action, only behaviour. I defend this claim in three steps. Firstly, I recapitulate some of the weighty grounds that speak in favour of animal agency. Secondly, I explain why I still doubt that animals act. The argument is that the account of agency that I take to be the most attractive one entails that animals can't act. Since this account of agency is non-standard, I spend the bulk of the paper with providing a sketch of what, according to it, actions are. Finally, I explain why it is still so natural and promising to regard animals as agents, although in fact they aren't. As one might put it: of course they act, only strictly speaking they don't.

机译：鉴于动物可以做许多奇妙的事情，而且我们在对动物采取有意的立场方面取得了成功，因此说动物根本不能行动似乎是不可想象的。尽管如此，这正是我所主张的。我声称严格来说，没有动物行动，只有行为。我分三步为这项主张辩护。首先，我总结一些有利于动物代理的重要理由。其次，我解释了为什么我仍然怀疑动物的行为。这种论点是，我认为是最有吸引力的代理机构意味着动物不能行动。由于代理机构的说明是非标准的，因此我在本文的大部分内容中都提供了有关行动依据的草图。最后，我解释了为什么将动物视为媒介仍然如此自然而有希望，尽管实际上并非如此。就像一个人所说：他们当然会行动，严格来说，他们不会。

著录项

来源
《Inquiry》 |2009年第3期|255-271|共17页
作者
RALF STOECKER;
展开▼
作者单位

Department of Philosophy, University of Potsdam, Universitaetsstrasse 10, 14469 Potsdam, Germany;

展开▼
收录信息美国《科学引文索引》(SCI);
原文格式 PDF
正文语种 eng
中图分类
关键词

相似文献

外文文献
中文文献
专利

1. Definitions of research animal, laboratory animal, laboratory animal veterinarian, research veterinarian, and research animal veterinarian (vol 258, pg 254, 2021) [J] . Hasenau Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association . 2021,第5期

机译：研究动物，实验室动物，实验室动物兽医，研究兽医和研究动物兽医的定义（Vol 258，PG 254,2021）
2. Self‐interest for the greater good . Review of Deckers , J ( 2016 ). Animal (De)liberation: Should the Consumption of Animals Be Banned? London : Ubiquity Press Self‐interest for the greater good Self‐interest for the greater good . Review of Deckers , J Deckers Deckers , J J ( 2016 2016 ). Animal (De)liberation: Should the Consumption of Animals Be Banned? London London : Ubiquity Press Ubiquity Press [J] . Laestadius Linnea I. Journal of evaluation in clinical practice . 2017,第5期

机译：自身利益更好。审查Deckers，J（2016）。动物（de）解放：是否应该禁止动物的消费？伦敦：笨拙的自我利益对于更好的良好的自身利益。审查Deckers，J Deckers Deckers，J J（2016年）。动物（de）解放：是否应该禁止动物的消费？伦敦伦敦：笨拙的新闻出版社
3. Fundamental Moral Attitudes to Animals and Their Role in Judgment: An Empirical Model to Describe Fundamental Moral Attitudes to Animals and Their Role in Judgment on the Culling of Healthy Animals During an Animal Disease Epidemic [J] . Nina E. Cohen, Frans W. A. Brom, Elsbeth N. Stassen Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics . 2009,第4期

机译：对动物的基本道德态度及其在判断中的作用：描述动物疾病流行期间对动物的基本道德态度及其在对健康动物的剔除判断中的作用的经验模型
4. Aspects of ethics and animal protection in animal husbandry under semi-natural conditions, in animals returned to the wild, and in wild animals [C] . K.M. Scheibe Congress of the European Society for Agricultural and Food Ethics . 2007

机译：半自然条件下畜牧业的道德和动物保护方面，动物归还野生动物，野生动物
5. Performing Animals: Analyzing Live Animals in the Arts and Their Impacts on our Environmental Perceptions of the Animal Other [D] . Frijia, Natalie Nicole. 2018

机译：表演动物：分析了艺术中的活动植物及其对我们对动物环境看法的影响
6. Instagranimal: Animal Welfare and Animal Ethics Challenges of Animal-Based Tourism [O] . Erica von Essen, Johan Lindsjö, Charlotte Berg 2020

机译：Instagranimal：动物旅游动物福利与动物伦理挑战
7. Article Tools Print this article Indexing metadata How to cite item Email this article Email the author About The Authors Tri Eko Susilorini Department of Animal Production, Faculty of Animal Husbandry, University of Brawijaya Indonesia Kuswati Kuswati Department of Animal Production, Faculty of Animal Husbandry, University of Brawijaya Indonesia Sucik Maylinda Department of Animal Production, Faculty of Animal Husbandry, University of Brawijaya Indonesia About RJLS Aim and Scope Editorial Board Reviewer Acknowledgement Publication Ethics Visitor Statistic Information for Author Author Guidelines (online version) Online Submission Guideline Online Registration Author Fees Download Template User You are logged in as... riris_rjlsub My Profile Log Out Tools Mendeley User Guide Insert Citation using Mendeley Journal Index Visitor Statistic Notifications View (28 new) Manage Journal Content Search Search Scope Browse By Issue By Author By Title Information For Readers For Authors For Librarians Keywords Antihypertensive Bali Strait Black Cincau (Mesona palustris BL) Effervescent Powder Coastal damage Financial Food composition ICP11 Litopenaeus vannamei Malondialdehyde Pandanus Plankton abundance RFLP Restoration plans for coastal villages Sardinella lemuru Sprinkle Stock Identification Village regulation WSSV Yellow stripe trevally and Morphometric mature B cells Polymorphism of Growth Hormone Gene in Selecting Etawah Crossbred (PE) Goats [O] . Tri Eko Susilorini, Kuswati Kuswati, Sucik Maylinda 2017

机译：文章工具打印本文索引元数据如何引用项目电子邮件本文通过电子邮件发送给作者关于作者TrieKo Susilorin系的动物生产系，畜牧业大学，Brawijaya大学Indonesia Kuswati Kuswati动物生产，畜牧业，大学of Brawijaya印度尼西亚Sucik Maylinda动物生产系，畜牧业，Brawijaya大学印度尼西亚关于RJLS AIM和范围编辑委员会审查者致谢出版道德访客统计信息作者指南（在线版）在线提交指南在线注册作者费用下载模板用户登录为... RIRIS_RJLSUB我的个人资料注销工具Mendeley用户指南插入引用使用Mendeley Journal Index访问者统计通知视图（28新）管理日志内容搜索范围按作者读取器的标题信息按问题浏览对于天秤座rians关键词抗高压性巴厘岛黑冰沙（Mesona Palustris BL）冒泡粉末沿海损伤金融食品成分ICP11 Litopenaeus Vannamei丙二醛丙烯醛帕尔图·佩斯纳斯巴姆斯（Pandanus Plankton丰富的RFLP恢复计划沿海村庄Sardinella Lemuru Sprines of Sprinks识别村监管WSSV黄色条纹Trevally和Morephorical成熟B细胞多态性选择Etawah杂交（PE）山羊的生长激素基因

Why Animals Can't Act

摘要

著录项

相似文献

相关主题

期刊订阅