Attitudes towards the role of Cost-Benefit Analysis in the decision-making process for spatial-infrastructure projects: A Dutch case study

Niek Mouter; Jan Anne Annema; Bert van Wee

首页> 外文期刊>Transportation Research >Attitudes towards the role of Cost-Benefit Analysis in the decision-making process for spatial-infrastructure projects: A Dutch case study

【24h】

Attitudes towards the role of Cost-Benefit Analysis in the decision-making process for spatial-infrastructure projects: A Dutch case study

机译：对成本效益分析在空间基础设施项目决策过程中的作用的态度：荷兰案例研究

获取原文

获取原文并翻译 | 示例

掌桥外文数据库（机构版） >>

开具论文收录证明 >>

文献代查 >>

页面导航

摘要
著录项
相似文献
相关主题

摘要

This paper provides a systematic overview of the attitudes of key actors in the Dutch Cost-Benefit Analysis (CBA) practice towards the role of CBA in the decision-making process for spatial-infrastructure projects. The main aim of this paper is to scrutinize the extent to which there is agreement among these Dutch actors in regard to the role of the CBA in the decision-making process. A secondary goal is to provide possible explanations for agreements and controversies among key actors in the Dutch CBA practice. In this study two research methods are combined to study the key actors' attitudes. Firstly, 86 key actors (e.g. consultants, scientists, policy makers) were interviewed in-depth. Secondly, 74 of them completed a written questionnaire. The most important conclusion of this paper is that in the Dutch CBA practice there is agreement that CBA must have a role in the appraisal process of spatial-infrastructure projects. However, there is a lot of controversy among economists and spatial planners in the Dutch CBA practice concerning the value that is and should be assigned to CBA in the decision-making process. Economists predominantly believe that not enough value is assigned to the CBA in the decision-making process, whereas spatial planners predominantly think that too much value is assigned to the CBA. Both economists and spatial planners believe that this controversy is problematic as it results in debates about the pros and cons of CBA instead of the pros and cons of the spatial-infrastructure projects. This paper analyzes some solutions for this controversy.

机译：本文系统地概述了荷兰成本效益分析（CBA）实践中关键角色对CBA在空间基础设施项目决策过程中的作用的态度。本文的主要目的是研究荷兰行为体在CBA在决策过程中的作用上达成共识的程度。第二个目标是为荷兰CBA惯例中的主要参与者之间的协议和争议提供可能的解释。在这项研究中，两种研究方法相结合来研究关键角色的态度。首先，对86位主要参与者（例如顾问，科学家，决策者）进行了深入访谈。其次，其中74人完成了书面问卷。本文最重要的结论是，在荷兰的CBA实践中，人们一致认为CBA必须在空间基础设施项目的评估过程中发挥作用。但是，在荷兰的CBA实践中，经济学家和空间规划师之间存在许多争议，涉及决策过程中应分配给CBA的价值。经济学家主要认为，在决策过程中没有将足够的价值分配给CBA，而空间规划师则主要认为为CBA分配了太多价值。经济学家和空间规划者都认为，这种争论是有问题的，因为这引起了关于CBA利弊的辩论，而不是关于空间基础设施项目的利弊的辩论。本文分析了该争议的一些解决方案。

著录项

来源
《Transportation Research》 |2013年第12期|1-14|共14页
作者
Niek Mouter; Jan Anne Annema; Bert van Wee;
展开▼
作者单位

Transport and Logistics Croup, Faculty of Technology, Policy and Management, Delft University of Technology, Jaffalaan 5, Delft 2628 BX, The Netherlands;

Transport and Logistics Croup, Faculty of Technology, Policy and Management, Delft University of Technology, Jaffalaan 5, Delft 2628 BX, The Netherlands;

Transport and Logistics Croup, Faculty of Technology, Policy and Management, Delft University of Technology, Jaffalaan 5, Delft 2628 BX, The Netherlands;

展开▼
收录信息
原文格式 PDF
正文语种 eng
中图分类
关键词
CBA; Cost-Benefit Analysis; Transport appraisal; Role of CBA in the decision-making process;

机译：CBA;成本效益分析;运输评估;CBA在决策过程中的作用;

相似文献

外文文献
中文文献
专利

1. Dutch politicians' attitudes towards Cost-Benefit Analysis [J] . Mouter Niek Transport policy . 2017,第Feba期

机译：荷兰政客对成本效益分析的态度
2. Decision-making On Mega-projects: Cost-benefit Analysis, Planning And Innovation. Hugo Priemus, Bent Flyvbjerg, Bert Van Wee, Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Uk (2008) [J] . Richard Knowles Journal of Transport Geography . 2008,第6期

机译：大型项目的决策：成本效益分析，规划和创新。雨果·普里默斯（Hugo Priemus），本特·弗莱比约格（Bent Flyvbjerg），贝特·范·维（Bert Van Wee），爱德华·埃尔加（Edward Elgar），英国切尔滕纳姆（Cheltenham）（2008）
3. Assessing public projects' value for money: An empirical study of the usefulness of cost-benefit analyses in decision-making [J] . Volden Gro Holst International Journal of Project Management . 2019,第4期

机译：评估公共项目的资金价值：对成本效益分析在决策中的作用的实证研究
4. A Study on Economic Appraisal for Railroad Construction Projects in China Using Multi-criteria Analysis in Conjunction with Cost-benefit Analysis [C] . CHEN Peihong, WANG Jiaqiong International conference on construction real estate management . 2007

机译：多准则分析与成本效益分析相结合的中国铁路建设项目经济评价研究
5. An alternative water resource project for the state of Colorado The Million - Green River Basin Water Project A comparative economics study and cost-benefit analysis of the Colorado River and Green River basins. [D] . Million, Aaron P. 2015

机译：科罗拉多州的另一个水资源项目百万-绿河流域水项目科罗拉多河和绿河流域的比较经济学研究和成本效益分析。
6. Decision-making is the process of analyzing information about a problem situation and comparing it to a specific conclusion in order to solve a specific problematic (Yıkılmaz, 2001; Miller and Byrnes, 2001). Decision-making styles are a mechanism that is influenced by the internal and external conditions that determine the direction of the decisions of the individual, the content of the decision-making process, and the outcome of the decision-making process (Payne, Bettman and Johson, 1993; Bavol’ár and Orosová, 2015). ACT is a contemporary member of the Cognitive Behavioral Therapy family. ACT (Acceptance and commitment therapy) has both similar and different directions with Behavioral Therapies and Cognitive Therapies (Herbet and Forman, 2011; Hayes, 2004). KKT responds to classical behavioral treatments using both existential and cognitive approaches in the analysis of behavior. KKT is a science wing that tries to solve human problems with a wider perspective aimed at solving problematic human behaviors (Plumb, Stewart, Dahl and Lundgren, 2009). It is seen that there is very little research about the new approach of ACT approach when the aiming country of our country is screened and it is thought that our country will contribute to the field of psychological counseling with the work done. In the scope of the research, experimental and control groups and preliminary test, post-test and follow-up measurements of 2x3 experimental design were used. The study's study group consists of a total of 24 (12 experimental and 12 control groups) university students studying in different departments and levels, continuing their education in the academic year of 2015-2016 in Ağrı province and İbrahim Chechen University in 2015-2016 academic year. The average age of participants in the experiment and control group is 20. There were 12 participants in the experimental group, 7 female and 5 male, and 12 participants, 7 female and 5 male in the control group. Personal Information Form and Decision Making Style Scale prepared by the researcher were used in the research. In order to decide on the tests to be used in the course of analyzing the data, the scores of the participant's Decision Styles Scale pre-test, which are placed primarily in the experimental and control groups, it was analyzed whether the basic expectations of parametric tests were answered. As a result of the analysis made, the scores, skewness and kurtosis coefficients obtained from the Decision Making Styles Scale were given to the experimental and control groups. It was determined that the distribution was normal in the result of Shapiro-Wilk test, in which the skewness and kurtosis coefficients of each sub-scale were ranked between -1 and +1. Participants in the experimental and control groups; homogeneity test results for decision-style pre-test measurements indicate that the data are homogeneous. According to the results of the Mauchly Globalness Test, it has been determined that working supports the hypothesis. It was determined that there was no significant difference between the pre-test scores obtained from dependent decision-making style of experiment and control groups, but the test group showed lower mean scores at the significant level within the scores of post-test and follow-up tests. Therefore, it can be said that the ACT-oriented psychoeducation program applied to the experimental group reduces the dependent decision-making style scores from the decision style sub-dimensions and the psychoeducation program has a lasting effect. It was determined that there was no significant difference between pre-test, post-test and follow-up scores obtained from the Spontaneous-Instant Decision Style of experiment and control groups. Thus, it can be said that this situation does not cause a significant difference in the Spontaneous-Decision-Making Style scores from the decision style sub-dimensions of the ACT-oriented psychoeducation program applied to the experimental group. The ACT -oriented psychoeducation program had a decline in the intuitive decision-making styles of the individuals, but this decrease did not create significant differences. Thus, it can be said that this situation does not make a meaningful difference in the intuitive decision style scores from the decision style sub-dimensions of the KKT oriented psychoeducation program applied to the experimental group. The pre-test scores obtained from the rational decision-making style of the experimental and control groups showed that there was a difference between the post-test and the follow-up scores, but this difference was not significant. As a result of the analysis, it was determined that the test group had higher levels of rational decision style than the pre - test scores in the post test and follow - up scores, whereas the post test and follow - up test scores in the control group rational decision style showed a decrease compared to the pre - test scores. the pre - test scores. Decision-making Styles Scale Avoidant Decision Making As a result of the analysis of the mean scores of the subscale scores of pre-test, post-test and follow-up measures, the group effect was found to be insignificant. It was determined that the experimental and control groups differed significantly from the pre-test scores obtained from the avoidant decision-making style but did not show any significant change within the scores of the post-test and follow-up tests. [O] . mustafa ercengiz, ali haydar şar 2018

机译：决策是分析有关问题情况的信息并将其与特定结论进行比较的过程，以解决特定的问题（Yıkılmaz，2001; Miller和Byrnes，2001）。决策风格是一种机制，受到内部和外部条件的影响，确定个人决定的方向，决策过程的内容以及决策过程的结果（PAYNE，BETTMAN和BEDNE） Johson，1993;Bavol'ár和奥萨洛瓦，2015）。法案是认知行为治疗家庭的当代成员。行为（验收和承诺治疗）具有与行为疗法和认知疗法的类似和不同方向（Herbet和Forman，2011; Hayes，2004）。 KKT在分析行为中使用存在性和认知方法来响应古典行为治疗方法。 KKT是一个科学翼，试图解决人类问题，旨在解决有问题的人类行为（铅垂，斯图尔特，Dahl和Lundgren，2009）。有人认为，当我们国家的瞄准国家进行筛选时，有关行动方法的新方法几乎没有研究，并且认为我们的国家将为完成工作做出贡献的心理咨询领域。在研究的范围内，使用实验和对照组和初步测试，使用后测试和后续测量的2x3实验设计。该研究的研究小组包括共24名（12个实验和12个对照组）大学学生在不同的部门和水平上学习，在2015-2016学术上继续进行2015-2016的学术年度2015-2016学年年。实验和对照组参与者的平均年龄是20.实验组中有12名参与者，7名女性和5名男性，12名参与者，7名女性和5名男性。研究人员准备的个人信息表格和决策制定风格规模在研究中使用。为了决定在分析数据的过程中使用的测试，参与者的决策风格刻度预测的分数主要在实验和对照组中进行，分析了参数的基本期望吗？测试得到了回答。由于对实验和对照组给出了从决策曲调标度获得的分数，偏移和峰度分子系数。确定该分布是正常的在成熟的-WILK试验结果中，其中每亚级的偏差和刚度系数在-1到+1之间排名。实验和对照组的参与者;决策式预测测量的同质性测试结果表明数据是均匀的。根据毛毛环保试验的结果，已确定工作支持假设。据确定，从依赖决策风格的实验和对照组获得的预测分数之间没有显着差异，但测试组在测试后的分数内显示出较低的平均分数和后续的分数 - 测试。因此，可以说，应用于实验组的面向活动的心理教育程序减少了决策风格子维度的依赖决策风格分数，并且心理教育程序具有持久的效果。据确定，从实验和对照组自发决策风格获得的预测试，测试后和后续评分之间没有显着差异。因此，可以说这种情况不会导致从应用于实验组的活动导向的心理教育程序的决策风格分数的自发决策风格分数显着差异。行为的心理教育计划在个人直观的决策风格下降，但这种减少并没有产生显着的差异。因此，可以说，这种情况不会在从应用于实验组的KKT导向的心理教育程序的决策风格分数中产生有意义的决策风格分数。从实验和对照组的理性决策风格获得的预测分数显示后检验后和随访评分之间存在差异，但这种差异并不重要。由于分析，确定测试组的理性决策风格较高，而不是后测试和后续分数的预测分数，而对照组合理决策风格的后测试和后续测试分数显示出与预测试分数相比的减少。预测分数。决策款式扩展避免决策由于分析了预测试，测试后和后续措施的班次评分的平均分数，发现群体效应是微不足道的。确定实验和对照组从避免决策风格获得的预测评分中显着不同，但在测试后和后续测试的分数内没有显示出任何重大变化。

Attitudes towards the role of Cost-Benefit Analysis in the decision-making process for spatial-infrastructure projects: A Dutch case study

摘要

著录项

相似文献

相关主题

期刊订阅