Just Procedures with Controversial Outcomes: On the Grounds for Substantive Disputation within a Procedural Theory of Justice

Emanuela Ceva

首页> 外文期刊>Res Publica >Just Procedures with Controversial Outcomes: On the Grounds for Substantive Disputation within a Procedural Theory of Justice

【24h】

Just Procedures with Controversial Outcomes: On the Grounds for Substantive Disputation within a Procedural Theory of Justice

机译：具有争议性结果的公正程序：基于程序正义论中的实质性争议

获取原文

获取原文并翻译 | 示例

掌桥外文数据库（机构版） >>

开具论文收录证明 >>

文献代查 >>

页面导航

摘要
著录项
相似文献
相关主题

摘要

Acts of civil disobedience and conscientious objection provide valuable indications of the congruence of political outcomes with citizens’ conceptions of justice and the good. As their primary concern is substantive, their logic seems extraneous to procedural approaches to justice. Accordingly, it has often been argued that these latter condemn citizens to a ‘deaf-and-blind’ acceptance of the outcomes of agreed procedures. A closer analysis of such acts of contestation shall reveal that although, for proceduralism, the outcomes of just procedures cannot be contested as unjust, they may be contested on the ground of values other than justice, such as someone’s religious/ethical allegiances. Proceduralism about justice will be thus shown to be consistent with the commitment to realising certain outcome-oriented values.

机译：公民抗命和出于良心拒服兵役的行为，为政治结果与公民的正义与善意的融合提供了宝贵的迹象。由于他们的主要关切是实质性的，因此他们的逻辑似乎与程序性司法方法无关。因此，经常有人争辩说，这些人谴责公民“盲目地”接受商定程序的结果。仔细分析这种争端行为，应该发现，尽管就程序主义而言，正义程序的结果不能被认为是不公正的，但它们可能会以正义以外的其他价值为由而争辩，例如某人的宗教/道德忠诚。因此，关于正义的程序主义将被证明与实现某些以结果为导向的价值的承诺是一致的。

著录项

来源
《Res Publica》 |2009年第3期|219-235|共17页
作者
Emanuela Ceva;
展开▼
作者单位

IUSS—Institute for Advanced Study, University of Pavia, Pavia, Italy;

展开▼
收录信息
原文格式 PDF
正文语种 eng
中图分类
关键词
Civil disobedience; Conscientious objection; Exemptions; Procedural justice; Substantive justice;

机译：公民抗命;出于良心反对;豁免;程序正义;实体正义;

相似文献

外文文献
中文文献
专利

1. Examining the Role of Substantive Justice in Planning Controversial Facilities [J] . Nino Antadze Environmental Justice . 2015,第5期

机译：审查实体司法在规划有争议设施中的作用
2. 'Just culture:' Improving safety by achieving substantive, procedural and restorative justice [J] . Dekker Sidney W. A., Breakey Hugh Safety science . 2016,第Null期

机译：“公正文化：”通过实现实质性，程序性和恢复性司法来改善安全
3. Some impediments in the Sri Lankan substantive and procedural law in achieving justice through forensics. [J] . Induwara Goonerathne Sri Lanka Journal of Forensic Medicine, Science & Law . 2013,第2期

机译：斯里兰卡的实体法和程序法在通过司法鉴定实现正义方面存在一些障碍。
4. Grounding collaborative work support system research in theory: the case for procedural justice theory [C] . Noel, T., Wynne, . 1991

机译：建立在理论基础上的协同工作支持系统研究：程序正义理论的案例
5. Innovative governance and natural resource management in Kenya: Procedural and substantive outcomes of civil society participation [D] . Okwako, Jane Omudho. 2015

机译：肯尼亚的创新治理和自然资源管理：民间社会参与的程序和实质性成果
6. Adaptation and innovation: a grounded theory study of procedural variation in the academic surgical workplace [O] . Tavis Apramian, Christopher Watling, Lorelei Lingard, -1

机译：适应与创新：学术外科工作场所程序变异的扎实理论研究
7. nyk of the Lviv University. Series Law KEYWORDS abuse of authority, abuse of power, abuse of official status, abuse of office acts of the European Union, international legal regulation, employment, right to free movement advocacy, advocate activity, advocacy science, advocatologie, theory of advocacy appeal proceeding, grounds to judgement revision, inconsistency of the court’s findings at first instance with the actual circumstances of the criminal proceedings, cancellation or alteration of the judgment charity organization, founder, assets of charity organization, constituent documents criminal proceedings, subjects of criminal proceedings, the suspect, the suspect law, criminal procedure, international standards employer’s duty, right to the moral injury compensation, social insurance from an industrial accident, social need, labour dispute forms of the legal actions of the collective of employees historical and legal science department, scientific activity law enforcement equipment, individual legal act, the means of forming the content of the enforcement act, requirements for registration of individual legal act attributes (properties) of acts of law legal formula (construction), qualified corpus delicti of a crime, degree of social danger, crime-forming feature legal social community legal technique, technology, legal act, legal system, lawmaking legitimacy, investigation of crime, concept of criminalistics, criminalistics recommendations, tactical methods measures aimed at providing criminal proceedings, procedural sanction, monetary penalty, pre-trial investigation national implementation, forms of implementation, implementation practice, European states, international treaties participant, shareholder, partnership, acquisition, changing, suspension proof, probability, likelihood, credibility in evidence, reliability scientific school, research, development land, agricultural and environmental law, Lviv Scientific School land, agricultural and environmental law the High Council of Justice of Ukraine, the National Council of Justice of the Republic of Poland, judges’ independence, international standards of the judiciary the presumption of the labor legal personality OPEN JOURNAL SYSTEMS Journal Help USER Username Password Remember me Login NOTIFICATIONS View Subscribe LANGUAGE Select LanguageSubmit JOURNAL CONTENT Search Search Scope Search Browse By Issue By Author By Title Other Journals FONT SIZE Make font size smallerMake font size defaultMake font size larger INFORMATION For Readers For Authors For Librarians HOME ABOUT LOGIN REGISTER SEARCH CURRENT ARCHIVES ANNOUNCEMENTS Home > No 67 (2018) > Марін ONCE AGAIN ON THE RETROACTIVE EFFECT OF THE CRIMINAL LAW IN TIME IN THE ASPECT OF INDIRECT CRIMINALIZATION [O] . Oleksandr Marin 2018

机译：LVIV大学的尼克。系列律师关键词滥用权威，滥用权力，滥用官方地位，滥用欧盟办公室行为，国际法律监管，就业，自由运动倡导，倡导活动，倡导科学，倡导性宣传理论，倡导呼吁的理论，理由修改，法院调查结果的不一致事实，判决慈善组织的实际情况，取消或改变判决慈善机构，慈善组织的创始人，慈善机构资产，组成文件刑事诉讼，刑事诉讼主题，嫌疑人，嫌疑法，刑事诉讼，国际标准雇主的责任，道德伤害赔偿权，社会保险从工业事故，社会需求，劳动争端形式的员工历史和法律科学部的法律行为，科学活动执法设备，个人法律法案，制定执法法案的内容，法律法律公式（建设）行为的个人法律法案（属性），犯罪的合格犯罪，社会危险程度，犯罪形成特征法律社会社会法律技术，技术，法律法，法律制度，立法合法性，犯罪调查，犯罪概念，犯罪建议，战术方法旨在提供刑事诉讼，程序制裁，货币罚款，预审调查预审国家实施，执行形式，实施实践，欧洲国家，国际条约参与者，股东，伙伴关系，收购，不断变化，暂停证明，概率，可能性，可信度在证据，可靠性科学学校，研究，开发土地，农业和环境法，利沃科学校园，农业和环境法律议理乌克兰的冰，波兰共和国国家司法委员会，法官的独立，国际标准的司法部门劳动法人的推定开放期刊系统期刊帮助用户用户名密码记住我登录通知查看订阅语言选择lobsumberubmit期刊内容搜索搜索范围搜索按问题浏览作者标题在间接刑事定罪方面，再次对刑法的追溯效应及时

Just Procedures with Controversial Outcomes: On the Grounds for Substantive Disputation within a Procedural Theory of Justice

摘要

著录项

相似文献

相关主题

期刊订阅