Criteria for assessing research quality in the humanities: A delphi study among scholars of english literature, german literature and art history

Hug S.E.; Ochsner M.; Daniel H.-D.

首页> 外文期刊>Research evaluation >Criteria for assessing research quality in the humanities: A delphi study among scholars of english literature, german literature and art history

【24h】

Criteria for assessing research quality in the humanities: A delphi study among scholars of english literature, german literature and art history

机译：评估人文学科研究质量的标准：英语文学，德国文学和艺术史学者之间的德尔菲研究

获取原文

获取原文并翻译 | 示例

掌桥外文数据库（机构版） >>

开具论文收录证明 >>

文献代查 >>

页面导航

摘要
著录项
相似文献
相关主题

摘要

How to assess research quality in the humanities is an intricate question. Despite the recent efforts of many initiatives, the measurement and assessment of research quality still faces strong opposition from humanities scholars, indicating that currently used evaluation schemes and tools are not tailored well enough to humanities disciplines. We have collected quality criteria from scholars in Switzerland and at League of European Research Universities (LERU) in the three disciplines, German literature studies, English literature studies and art history with a multiround Delphi survey. The first Delphi round resulted in a comprehensive list of 19 criteria of good research specified by 70 aspects. Although 10 of these criteria are well known and commonly used in various evaluation schemes, nine criteria are not, or at least not frequently, employed in evaluation schemes. In the second Delphi round, consensual criteria and aspects (i.e. items that were clearly approved by a majority and disapproved by very few scholars) were identified in each discipline. Specifically, 11 criteria reached consensus in all three disciplines (shared criteria), six criteria were consensual in only one or two disciplines (discipline-specific criteria) and two criteria were not consensual in any discipline (i.e. 'productivity' and 'relation to and impact on society'). The results of this study corroborate previous findings that researchers have not yet adopted Mode 2-related assessment criteria. Implications for research assessment are being discussed. The focus lies in particular on the mismatch of criteria between evaluators and scholars as well as on an approach to bridge such a mismatch.

机译：如何评估人文学科的研究质量是一个复杂的问题。尽管最近已采取了许多举措，但对研究质量的评估和评估仍面临人文学者的强烈反对，这表明当前使用的评估方案和工具还不足以适应人文学科。我们通过多次德尔菲调查，从瑞士和欧洲研究大学联盟（LERU）的三个学科，德国文学研究，英国文学研究和艺术史的学者那里收集了质量标准。第一轮Delphi回合产生了由70个方面指定的19项良好研究标准的综合清单。尽管这些标准中有10条是众所周知的，并且通常在各种评估方案中使用，但是在评估方案中没有或至少不经常使用9条标准。在第二轮德尔菲回合中，每个学科都确定了共识的标准和方面（即被多数人明确批准而很少学者拒绝的项目）。具体而言，在所有三个学科（共同的标准）中有11条标准达成共识，在一个或两个学科（特定学科的标准）中只有6条标准是一致的，而在任何学科中都没有两个标准（即“生产力”和“与……的关系”）是一致的。对社会的影响”）。这项研究的结果证实了以前的发现，即研究人员尚未采用与模式2相关的评估标准。正在讨论对研究评估的意义。重点尤其放在评估者和学者之间的标准不匹配以及弥合这种不匹配的方法上。

著录项

来源
《Research evaluation》 |2013年第5期|共15页
作者
Hug S.E.; Ochsner M.; Daniel H.-D.;
展开▼
作者单位

展开▼
收录信息
原文格式 PDF
正文语种 eng
中图分类自然科学总论;社会科学总论;
关键词
Art history; Delphi survey; English literature studies; German literature studies; Humanities; Leru; Quality criteria; Research evaluation; Research quality;

机译：美术史;德尔福调查;英语文学研究;德语文学研究;人文;勒鲁;质量标准;研究评价;研究质量;

相似文献

外文文献
中文文献
专利

1. Criteria for assessing research quality in the humanities: A delphi study among scholars of english literature, german literature and art history [J] . Hug S.E., Ochsner M., Daniel H.-D. Research evaluation . 2013,第5期

机译：评估人文学科研究质量的标准：英语文学，德国文学和艺术史学者之间的德尔菲研究
2. History of German Literature, vol 10, History of German Literature from 1918 to 1933 [J] . Smith Helmut Walser Ecological restoration . 2020,第1期

机译：德国文学的历史，第10卷，德国文学史从1918年到1933年
3. Global English in the Humanities? A Longitudinal Citation Study of Foreign-Language Use by Humanities Scholars [J] . Charlene Kellsey, Jennifer E. Knievel College & Research Libraries . 2004,第3期

机译：人文学科的全球英语？人文学者对外国语言使用的纵向引证研究
4. Since the Founding of New China, the English Literature on the Progress of Martial Arts Research and Hot Sports‐‐‐‐‐Based on the Web of Science Core Collection Database Literature [C] . Li Longfei International Conference on Modern Education and Information Management . 2020

机译：自新中国成立以来，英国文学对武术研究和热门运动的进步-----基于科学核心收集数据库文学
5. A content analysis of literature written in South Midland dialect; and a study of the knowledge, attitudes, and practices of middle school language arts and secondary English teachers related to dialect in literature and in the classroom. [D] . Eilers, Ulinda J. 1999

机译：对南米德兰方言文学作品的内容分析；对中学语言艺术和中学英语教师在文学和课堂中与方言有关的知识，态度和实践的研究。
6. Abstract: Assessing Quality in Systematic Reviews: Application of AMSTAR Criteria to Plastic Surgery Literature [O] . Hillary E. Jenny, Benjamin B. Massenburg, Joseph Leanza, 2016

机译：摘要：系统评价的质量评估：AMSTAR标准在整形外科文献中的应用
7. Reviews: The Study of History: A Bibliographical Guide, the English Idea of History from Coleridge to Collingwood, the Changing Face of English Local History, Arthur and the English: The Arthurian Legend in Medieval English Life and Literature, Enacting Gender on the English Renaissance Stage, Shakespeare's Feminine Endings, Writing the English Republic: Poetry, Rhetoric and Politics 1627–1660, New Stories for Old: Biblical Patterns in the Novel, Catholicism and Anti-Catholicism in Early Modern English Texts, Primogeniture and Entail in England: A Survey of Their History and Representation in Literature, the English Civil War Through the Restoration in Fiction: An Annotated Bibliography, Diana, Self-Interest, and British National Identity, Dryden and the Traces of Classical Rome, between the Ancients and the Moderns: Baroque Culture in Restoration England, Bacchus in Romantic England: Writers and Drink, 1780–1830, Misogynous Economies: The Business of Literature in Eighteenth-Century Britain, the House of Forgery in Eighteenth-Century Britain, the Clothes That Wear Us, An Oxford Companion to the Romantic Age: British Culture, 1776–1832, Domestic Space: Reading the Nineteenth-Century Interior, Victorians in Theory: From Derrida to Browning, the Age of Virtue: British Culture from the Restoration to Romanticism, Woeful Afflictions: Disability and Sentimentality in Victorian America, Women Writers of the First World War: An Annotated Bibliography, the Pub in Literature, British Industrial Fictions, the Insatiability of Human Wants: Economics and Aesthetics in Market SocietyRichardsonR. C., The Study of History: A Bibliographical Guide , 2nd ed., Manchester University Press, 2000, pp. xiv + 140, £40.00.ParkerChristopher, The English Idea of History from Coleridge to Collingwood , Ashgate Publishing, 2000, pp. vii + 244, £45.RichardsonR. C. (ed.), The Changing Face of English Local History , Ashgate, 2000, pp. viii + 218, £45.00.BarronW. R. J. (ed.), Arthur and the English: The Arthurian Legend in Medieval English Life and Literature , University of Wales Press, 1999, pp. 398, £35.00.ComensoliViviana and RussellAnne (eds), Enacting Gender on the English Renaissance Stage , University of Illinois Press, 1999, pp. 270, £18.95; SaundersEve Rachel, Gender and Literacy on Stage in Early Modern England , Cambridge University Press, 1999, pp. 260, £35.BerryPhilippa, Shakespeare's Feminine Endings , Routledge, 1999, pp. 197, £15.99 pb.; BellIlona, Elizabethan Women and the Poetry of Courtship , Cambridge University Press, 1998, pp. 262, £35.00.NorbrookDavid, Writing the English Republic: Poetry, Rhetoric and Politics 1627–1660 , Cambridge University Press, 1999, pp. xiii + 509, £40.FischHarold, New Stories for Old: Biblical Patterns in the Novel , Macmillan, 1998, pp. x + 236, £42.50; FischHarold, The Biblical Presence in Shakespeare, Milton and Blake , Clarendon Press, 1999, pp. xi + 330, £45.MarottiArthur F. (ed.), Catholicism and Anti-Catholicism in Early Modern English Texts , Macmillan, 1999, pp. xvii + 266, £47.50; ShellAlison, Catholicism, Controversy and the English Literary Imagination, 1558–1660 , Cambridge University Press, 1999, pp. xi + 309, £37.50.JamoussiZouheir, Primogeniture and Entail in England: A Survey of their History and Representation in Literature , Centre de Publication Universitaire, Tunis, 1999, pp. 293, 8 DT.MurphRoxane C., The English Civil War through the Restoration in Fiction: An Annotated Bibliography , Greenwood Press, Westport, CT., 2000, pp. viii + 349, £63.95.HammondPaul, Dryden and the Traces of Classical Rome , Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1999, pp. 305, £45.00.LevineJoseph M., Between the Ancients and the Moderns: Baroque Culture in Restoration England , Yale University Press, 1999, pp. xiv + 279, £27.50.TaylorAnya, Bacchus in Romantic England: Writers and Drink, 1780–1830 , Macmillan, 1999, pp. xi + 264, £47.50.MandellLaura, Misogynous Economies: The Business of Literature in Eighteenth-century Britain , University of Kentucky, 1999, pp. x + 228, $42.00.BainesPaul, The House of Forgery in Eighteenth-century Britain , Ashgate, 1999, pp. viii + 195, £47.50.MunnsJessica and RichardsPenny (eds), The Clothes that Wear Us , Newark, University of Delaware Press, 1999, pp. 362, £37.McCalmanIain (ed.), An Oxford Companion to the Romantic Age: British Culture, 1776–1832 , Oxford University Press, 1999, p. xii + 780, £85.BrydenInga and FloydJanet (eds), Domestic Space: Reading the Nineteenth-century Interior , Manchester University Press, 1999, pp. xii + 219, £40.00; KiddAlan and NichollsDavid (eds), Gender, Civic Culture and Consumerism: Middle-class Identity in Britain 1800–1940 , Manchester University Press, 1999, pp. xiv + 223, £46.00, pb. £14.99.SchadJohn Victorians in Theory: From Derrida to Browning , Manchester University Press, 1999, pp. x + 180, £40.MorseDavid, The Age of Virtue: British Culture from the Restoration to Romanticism , Macmillan, 2000, pp. viii + 330, £45.KlagesMary, Woeful Afflictions: Disability and Sentimentality in Victorian America , University of Pennsylvania Press, 1999, pp. 211, $36.50.OudittSharon, Women Writers of the First World War: An Annotated Bibliography , Routledge, 2000, pp. 230, £75; TyleeClaire with TurnerElaine and CardinalAgnes (eds), War Plays by Women: An International Anthology , Routledge, 2000, pp. 225, £16.99 pb.TaylorJohn A., Diana, Self-Interest, and British National Identity , Praeger, 2000, pp. 169, £44.95.EarnshawSteven, The Pub in Literature , Manchester University Press, 2000, pp. x + 294, £45 and £15.99 pb.KlausH. Gustav and KnightS. (eds), British Industrial Fictions , University of Wales Press, 2000, pp. viii + 212, £14.99 pb.; BalchJack S., Lamps at High Noon , University of Illinois Press, 2000, pp. xl + 404, $19.45 pb.; ConroyJack, A World to Win , University of Illinois Press, 2000, pp. xxxv + 348, $17.95 pb.GagnierRegenia, The Insatiability of Human Wants: Economics and Aesthetics in Market Society , University of Chicago Press, 2000, pp. 352, £10.50 pb. [O] . Paul Hyland, R. C. Richardson, Ivan Roots, 2001

机译：点评：历史的研究：一个书目指南，历史的英语理念从柯勒律治到科林伍德，英国当地历史，亚瑟和他的英语变脸：亚瑟王传说中中世纪英国生活和文学，在英国文艺复兴时期颁布性别舞台上，莎士比亚的女性结局，写英文共和国：诗歌，修辞学和政治学1627年至1660年，对旧的新故事：在小说中，天主教和反天主教在早期现代英语文本，长子继承权和继承权在英国圣经模式：综述文学中的历史和代表，通过对小说恢复的英语内战：一个注释的参考书目，戴安娜，自我利益和英国国家身份，古人与现代人之间的古典罗马的痕迹和古典罗马：巴洛克文化在恢复英格兰，浪漫英格兰的Bacchus：1780-1830，厌恶经济学的作家和饮料：十八世纪的文学业务ritain，伪造的房子在十八世纪的英国，穿着我们的衣服，牛津伴侣的浪漫时代：英国文化，1776 - 1832，国内空间：阅读十九世纪的内部，维多利亚人理论上：从德里达到布朗，美德的年龄：英国文化从恢复到浪漫主义，悲惨的痛苦：维多利亚州的残疾和感情，妇女作家第一次世界大战：一个注释的书目，文学中的酒吧，英国工业小说，人类的缘故想要：市场苏格里希第德森市场的经济和美学。 C.，历史的研究：一个书目指南，第二版，曼彻斯特大学出版社，2000，第十四+ 140，£40.00.ParkerChristopher，历史的英语从理念到柯勒律治科林伍德，Ashgate出版社，2000，页。 VII + 244，£45.Richardsonr。 C.（ed。），英语当地历史的变化面孔，ashgate，2000，pp。viii + 218，£45.00.00.00.Parronw。 RJ（编辑），亚瑟和他的英文：亚瑟王传说中中世纪英国生活和文学，威尔士出版社，1999年大学，第398，£35.00.ComensoliViviana和RussellAnne（EDS），英国文艺复兴舞台上颁布性别，伊利诺伊大学出版社，1999，第270页，18.95英镑; SaunderseVe Rachel，在早期现代英格兰舞台上的雷切尔，性别和识字，剑桥大学出版社，1999，PP。260，£35.BerringPhilippa，莎士比亚的女性化的遗址，Routledge，1999，PP。197，£15.99 PB。 Bellilona，伊丽莎白裔女性和甲师诗歌，剑桥大学出版社，1998，PP。262，£35.00.norbrookdavid，写英国共和国：诗歌，修辞和政治1627-1660，剑桥大学出版社，1999，PP。XIII + 509 ，£40.FischHarold，对于旧的新故事：在小说，Macmillan出版社，1998年，第圣经模式X + 236，£42.50; Fischharold，Shakespeare，Milton和Blake的圣经存在，1999年，PP。Xi + 330，£45.marottiarthur F.（Ed。），天主教和早期现代英语文本，Macmillan，1999，PP的天主教和反天主教。XVII + 266，£47.50; Shellalison，天主教，争议和英国文学想象，1558-1660，剑桥大学出版社，1999，PP。XI + 309，£37.50.Jamoussizouheir，Punigoghts和Envland在英国：他们在文学中的历史和代表调查，中心出版大学，突尼斯，1999，PP。293,8 DT.Murphorn Xane C.，英语内战通过虚构的恢复：一个注释书目，格林伍德出版社，韦斯特波特，CT，CT。，2000，PP。VIII + 349，£63.95 .HammondPaul，德莱顿和古典罗马，克拉伦登出版社，牛津，1999年的痕迹，第305，£45.00.LevineJoseph M.，古人和现代人之间：巴洛克文化恢复英格兰，耶鲁大学出版社，1999，页。 XIV + 279，£27.50.50.50.5.50.Tayloranya，浪漫英格兰的Bacchus：作家和饮料，1780-1830，Macmillan，1999，PP。Xi + 264，£47.50.Mandelllaura，罕有内容：十八世纪英国的文学业务，肯塔基州大学，1999，PP。X + 228，$ 42.00.Bainespaul，在十八世纪的英国伪造之家，阿什捷，1999年，PP。第八次+ 195，£47.50.50.50.50.Munnsjessica和Richardspenny（EDS），穿着我们，纽瓦克，特拉华大学出版社，1999，PP。362，£ 37.McCalmanIain（编辑），牛津伴侣对浪漫的年龄：英国文化，1776年至1832年，牛津大学出版社，1999，页。 XII + 780，£85.Brydeninga和Floydjanet（EDS），国内空间：阅读十九世纪内部，曼彻斯特大学出版社，1999，PP。XII + 219，£40.00; KiddAlan和NichollsDavid（EDS），性别，公民文化和消费：在英国，1800年至1940年中产阶层的身份，曼彻斯特大学出版社，1999年，第十四+ 223，£46.00，PB。 14.99英镑的理论上，从Derrida到Browning，曼彻斯特大学出版社，1999年，PP。X + 180，£40.Moreedavid，富于浪漫主义，2000，2000，PP。八+ 330，£45.Klesmary，悲惨的痛苦：宾夕法尼亚大学的维多利亚州美国的残疾和感情，1999年，第211次，第一次第一次世界大战的妇女作家：一名注册参考书目，rutledge，2000，pp。230，75英镑; TyleeClaire与Turnerelaine和Cardinalagnes（EDS），战争扮演妇女：国际选集，Routledge，2000，PP。225，£16.99 PB.Taylorjohn A.，戴安娜，自身利益和英国国家身份，Praeger，2000，PP 。169，£44.95.EARNShawsteven，文学中的酒吧，曼彻斯特大学出版社，2000，PP。X + 294，£45和15.99英镑PB.Klaush。古斯塔夫和骑士。（EDS），英国工业小说，威尔士大学出版社，2000，PP。VIII + 212，£14.99 PB。 Balchjack S.，伊利诺伊大学高中中午的灯，2000年，PP。XL + 404，$ 19.45 PB。康罗伊士队，伊利诺伊大学的世界胜利，2000年，PP。XXXV + 348，17.95磅PB.Gagnierregenia，人类想要的缘故：市场学会的经济学和美学，芝加哥大学出版社，2000，PP。352，£ 10.50 PB。

Criteria for assessing research quality in the humanities: A delphi study among scholars of english literature, german literature and art history

摘要

著录项

相似文献

相关主题

期刊订阅