Goerdt [Goe91] considered a weakened version of the Cutting Plane proof system with a restriction on the degree of falsity of intermediate inequalities. (The degree of falsity of an inequality written in the form Σ a_ix_i+ Σ b_i(1 - x_i) ≥ A, a_i, b_i ≥ 0 is its constant term A.) He proved a superpolynomial lower bound on the proof length of Tseitin-Urquhart tautologies when the degree of falsity is bounded by n/(log~2n+1) (n is the number of variables). In this paper we show that if the degree of falsity of a Cutting Planes proof Π is bounded by d(n) ≤ n/2, this proof can be easily transformed into a resolution proof of length at most ∣Π∣·(n/(d(n)-1)64~(d(n)). Therefore, an exponential bound on the proof length of Tseitin-Urquhart tautologies in this system for d(n) ≤ cn for an appropriate constant c > 0 follows immediately from Urquhart's lower bound for resolution proofs [Urq87].
展开▼
